Monday, May 5, 2014
Mars challenges Hershey’s over the use of the name Malteser in USIn the battle for marketshare in the confectionery sector, it seems that some candy companies are more interested in getting our business by eliminating competition than gaining brand loyalty with exemplary products. The latest battle involves old rivals Hershey and Mars, this time over malted milk balls. Mars makes Maltesers and Hershey’s makes Whoppers. But Hershey’s is also trying to assert the exclusive right to also make something called Malteser in the United States. I don’t have the figures, but I’m going to guess that Hershey’s holds more than 70% of the market in malted milk balls with their Whoppers brand, but not necessarily because they’re the best but because they’re ubiquitous. Though I don’t have current figures, I’d estimate the brand is worth about $40 to $50 million in sales a year. Here’s a little history. Mars Maltesers were first sold in the United Kingdom in 1937. They were created as a diet candy; a chocolate candy with less chocolate and therefore less fat and calories. They’re also sold in Canada, New Zealand and Australia and exported to many other European countries. They can be purchased in shops that specialize in UK imports. Based on the number of brand extensions I’ve seen for Maltesers on my recent trip to London, I’d say that the candy is a much more important brand to Mars than Whoppers are to Hershey’s. Which may make them appear a threat. In 1939 an American candy company called Overland, introduced a malted milk ball candy sold under the name Giants, as they were larger than earlier versions called Malt-ettes. In 1949, two years after the company was sold to Leaf Inc, they were renamed Whoppers. There were many other companies that came and went that sold malted milk balls, but Whoppers have been made continuously ever since, even if their corporate overlords have changed. Leaf Inc was once a formidable sugar candy company, the fourth largest in the US. They acquired many favorite American candy brands, including Jolly Rancher, Hollywood Brands (maker of Payday bars), Heath Bar, and Now and Later. Sometime in the 1960s Leaf started making something called Malteser and even registered a trademark for the name in 1962. I doubt they were widely distributed or advertised, as I can’t find any record of them . In 1983 Leaf was bought out by Huhtamäki Oyj, a Finnish company, which maintained the trademark registration. Mars sued Leaf over this trademark in 1993 and later settled out of court (so we don’t know the details) but Leaf retained the trademark. For reasons I don’t quite understand, Leaf Inc divested and sold off many of its best brands, most to Hershey’s: Whoppers, Payday, Jolly Rancher and Heath Bar. Fast forward and lately Hershey’s has been releasing a product called Matleser: a malted milk ball that in all ways except packaging is identical to Whoppers. Though it’s a singular in the name, not Maltesers as the Mars product is, it’s also packaged in red. The way trademarks work, not only do you need to register the trademark in all territories you plan to exercise it, you also need to use it. So if Hershey’s wanted to keep Mars from using Malteser in the US, by claiming it was an abandoned trademark, they had to demonstrate that Hershey’s wasn’t using it. I was able to find Hershey’s Malteser for sale on both the Hershey’s site and Amazon. I bought a box to confirm that they are just Whoppers in a different package. (They are.) Mars contends that not only is Hershey’s squatting on the trademark in the United States, but that their packaging is intentionally confusing consumers to think that they’re purchasing the Mars version. I admit, they do look similar and even though I’m the candy blogger, I couldn’t remember of the top of my head if the Mars version was plural or singular until I started this research. American trademark law is governed for the most part under the Lanham Act which covers trademark infringement and false advertising. The act was also revised in 1999 to encompass cybersquatting, the practice of registering domain names and then sitting on them or directing them to a competitor. While Hershey’s practices up to the point where they created similar packaging were probably within the letter, though not the spirit of the law, my opinion after looking at the history, reading Mars’ brief on the case leads me to conclude that Hershey’s is just acting scummy. Whoppers are known by 300 million people in this country ... and if it’s not a favorable brand then Hershey’s should improve their quality, price point or packaging to the point where people are loyal to them.
I tried both again, just to check. Neither is great, but the do differ. Both have a mockolate coating, though the Mars version does have some cocoa butter in there. The centers, though both malty, have different textures. The Mars version is more honeycombed and has a easier crunch. The Hershey’s version is more milky tasting with a firm crunch that dissolves nicely. Both are excellent centers ... both have disappointing coatings. I prefer the Mars Maltesers.
I’m a extremely curious if Mars were to introduced Maltesers in the United States if they would change the coating to real chocolate, as they do not make any mockolate products for the American market. However, Mars does not have a good track record for introducing the European candies to the US when there is another similar candy already on the market. They tried this with the Bounty bars, which are similar to Mounds and Almond Joy and they never took hold. Twix was a European launch that was then introduced in the US, but is a unique candy construction, which is how it established itself in its niche. This is not an isolated issue in the candy business. Many candy companies go head to head in the courts instead of on the store shelves. - The UK the courts have been deciding whether Cadbury should have exclusive rights to their shade of purple. Currently, the answer is no. For more reading on the issue, here are some other trade articles on the case: Related Candies
POSTED BY Cybele AT 11:41 am Candy • Hershey's • Mars • Malt • Mockolate • United Kingdom • United States • Highlight • News • |
||||
ABOUT
FEEDSCONTACT
EMAIL DIGESTCANDY RATINGSTYPE
BRAND
COUNTRY
ARCHIVES
|
Meticulously photographed and documented reviews of candy from around the world. And the occasional other sweet adventures. Open your mouth, expand your mind.
|
What an odd development. What is Hershey’s endgame here? “Whoppers” is such an ingrained name for malted milk balls in the US, I don’t get the point of this at all.
There’s also been a dispute over M&M’s and a similar product called “M’s” in Sweden:
http://www.confectionerynews.com/Manufacturers/Mars-and-Mondelez-wage-M-M-s-trademark-war-in-Sweden
I reviewed “M’s” here:
http://kevssnackreviews.blogspot.co.uk/2013/10/kraft-marabou-m-chocolate-coated-peanuts-mars.html
I’m an intellectual property lawyer by day and I hadn’t heard about these cases. What a great analysis and a fascinating post! Thanks for sharing it.
It’s true that Mars (UK) chocolate isn’t “real” chocolate by any international standard. However, Hershey’s standard chocolate bar is quite the most awful tasting “chocolate” that anyone should have to suffer.
You’re right, Hershey’s is acting really scummy with this. How much of their profit would they even lose to Malteser? Probably a negligible amount.
Also, when I was in Dubai, where a lot of European sweets are available, I had several knock-off KitKats that were really very good, and something I would buy in their own right.
Hersheys is absolutely disgusting, their chocolate tastes like I threw up on my mouth. Mars and Maltesers are great, NOTHING beats british chocolate.
I bought a bag of Hershey’s Malteser thinking it was Mars Maltesers and was very disappointed
Cybele:
In addition, of course, to Seven Up Bar (Boy!does that one take me back to 1974 and earlier to the early 60s) and Seven Up Soda, there is Seven Up Bar and Sky Bar. Necco has always made (NOT licensed, folks) the SkyBar, which has almost half the number of flavors as did the Seven Up bars, but I can’t recall the Seven Up bar maker….
I have to agree that the knockoff name is very misleading. As the owner of a candy store I have people who ask for British candy. I was checking out my weekly coupon for the local movie theater and they were offering free malteser with a coke purchase. So then of course I had to start researching how malteser was in America. Hershey needs to loose this battle. They are definitely trading in on someone else"s branded identity
There are ads in US theatres foir Maltesers with two British chicks reluctantly trying them…the disclaimer apopears at the end, “Only in Theatres” but the theateres I’ve been to DON’T have them. Heck, explains it..
Next entry: Eat with your Eyes: Monopoly Gummi Cars
Previous entry: Cadbury Dairy Milk Pebbles