I know, I might be in the majority, but I LOVE THESE, I just can’t help myself!  Is there anyone else out there who does????

I wasn’t too nuts about them. I think I was expecting something way different. I’ll take a normal Reese’s Cup any day!

OOPs I just reread mine, I meant to say that I MIGHT BE IN THE MINORITY!!!  LOL!  So sorry!

They’re not bad, but by the end of one I always feel a little sick. Maybe a little too sweet- and nothing in the world can match the crumbly, salty goodness in the middle of a Reese’s Cup…

I dunno I just love them!!!!

My husband liked them as well, but I found them to be too sweet. I think the problem with any new product with peanut butter and chocolate (especially made by Reese’s) is that I will always compare it to a Reese’s cup which is really just the perfect food so of course everything else disappoints.

Good point!  Reese’s cups are very good…..and my real fave is the Peanut Butter Eggs/Trees/Pumpkins

I think they’re excellent. Now they just need to make a white chocolate version (even more in the minority now…).

AAARRRGGGHHH White chocolate, my least fave.

Nope, I wasn’t a big fan of these. I spit out my sample.

I also love these, thet are great when you are ona diet and want a Resse Cup since they have fewer calories.

I’d be more satified eating one miniature reese cup than I would be eating a whole whipps bar

quality > quantity

Not me I am a candy addict. One would just be a tease or a torture. That’s why now the ordinary cup won’t even please me. I have to eat the new Thicker cup with more chocolate.

I thought the Whipps was pretty good! I can’t say I’d get it over a Peanut Butter Cup, but I certainly didn’t mind eating the.. err.. couple… that I had!

I found that the whip was actually very bland. I couldn’t really taste any of the delicious, salty peanut butter that I’m used to. I understand that it is SUPPOSED to be fluffy and airy but it takes away from the taste of the actual candy piece itself. Half the fat, half the flavor.

2 out of 5 for me.

No doubt, they’re not as peanutty as a Reeses cup, but they’re darn tasty.  They remind me of peanut butter mixed with marshmallow fluff (flavorwise if not texturewise).